Template:— assigning_descriptor (asg_descr) Date: 2008/03/08 14:52:57
Revision: 1.17
CoverContentsDescriptionModel diags.Input params.Ref. params.Instantiation pathInstance diags.CharacterizationsIssues

Issue raised against: assigning_descriptor

GENERAL issues

Closed issue Issue: RBN-1 by Rob Bodington (07-03-16) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

The classification of the description should default to "Description" This should be set on the template parameters
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 07-04-16)
Rejected. The purpose of using the name "Descriptor" is to allow for multiple types of textual annotations such as "Description", "Note", "Remark" etc.

Closed issue Issue: TJT-1 by Tim Turner, LSC (04/09/2007) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Parse error by Graphical Instance vn 1.0.5.20; Element content is invalid according to the DTD/Schema. Expecting: template_example at line 190: See figure id="assigning_descriptor_inst_tmpl"
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. Can not reproduce the referenced error.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-1 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-7-24) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 11 XML not valid, >instance_diagram_example..< not valid element type. Should be template_example
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. Can not reproduce the referenced error using Oxygen XML editor. According to Oxygen is the >instance_diagram_example a valid element wherer it is.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-2 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-7-24) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 14 Hyperlink for Descriptor_assignment does not use rdl_ref but >class id="" urn=""<, >param_ref...< used for reference parameters with invalid link.
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. Review item adresses hyperlinks in descriptions. Issue is raised against declaration of input parameter.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-3 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-7-24) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 15 Reference to Document and Document_assignment in stepmod, not valid link.
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. The intension of this review item was that modules in stepmod shouldn't be referenced explicitly. However, Entities needs to be referenced! Issue to be raised against template checklist.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-4 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-8-27) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 16 Figure hyperlinks does not exist with >figure_ref..<
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. No references are made within the text that needs to be hyperlinked.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-5 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-8-27) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 19 Name of model reviwer and business reviewer missing.
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. Organization is valid reviewer.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-6 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-8-27) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 20 Status set to In_model_review not end_modelling.
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. Intension of checklist was that status should have passed the stage of 'end_modelling'

Closed issue Issue: DNV-7 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-7-24) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 24 Description does not explain what is meant by descriptor.
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Added a note to the description section, with the purpose of clarifying the intestion of descriptor

Closed issue Issue: DNV-8 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-7-24) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 49 Template parameters does not include reference to constant class name "Descriptor" and its external_class_library
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. Constants within the template shall not be part of the input (template) parameters.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-9 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-7-24) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 51 Input parameter descr is not described satisfactory, should not use class name "Descriptor" as part of descripton
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. Do not understand the value of adding information about the Descriptor as part of the input parameter description. Would probably just be confusing when used in template tables.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-10 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-7-24) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 53 The super class for paramteter class_name is wrong, should be "Description" not "Descriptor_assignment"
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. Class Description is a subtype of the Descriptor_assignment Class, as well as the Remark and Note Classes.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-11 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-7-24) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 73 The URN "urn:plcs:rdl:std" is used when it should have been urn:plcs:rdl:sample for example
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Rejected. Both 'Description' and 'Descriptor' are classes defined within urn:plcs:rdl:std. The URN urn:plcs:rdl:sample is supposed to be used when there are no refdata available in order to provide a meaningful example.

Closed issue Issue: DNV-12 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-7-24) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 82 Template unique object identifier is not the same as inside the grey box.
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)
Corrected

Closed issue Issue: DNV-13 by Fredrik Lied Larsen, DNV (2007-8-27) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: template_issues_Frell.xls Template: assigning_descriptor Check list clause: 90 Missing EXPRESS-G diagram for characterization. Wrong referencing template for date, should not be assigning_calendar_date, but assigning_time.
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)

First part of the issue rejected. Diagrams are not mandated for Characterization section.

Second part accepted. Changed usage of template from assigning_calendar_date to assigning_time.

Closed issue Issue: RBN-2 by Rob Bodington (07-11-04) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

The parameters should have a default: class_name default = Descriptor_assignment ecl_id default = urn:plcs:rdl:std
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-01-21)

Added 'Description' as the default class for input parameter class_name.

Added 'urn:plcs:rdl:std' as the default value for input parameter ecl_id.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 08-01-31)
The default is either Description or Descriptor_assignment - which is used to indicate that something is a descriptor?

Closed issue Issue: RBN-3 by Rob Bodington (08-03-08) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

The EXPRESS_g diagram and path show class "Descriptor" - BUT the input parameter and instance diagrams show "Description". Propose to change to use "Description"
Comment: (Rob Bodington 08-03-08)
Corrected
Comment: (Leif Gyllstrom 08-03-08)
Chage rolled back after discussion with Rob B.