Issues raised against the ISO 10303-239.

Issue file: dexlib/docs/issues/ap239_issues.xml

This issue log maintains a record of all the issues raised against AP239. These issues need to be raised as SEDS against the relevant module and addressed in a later revision of the modules.

When adding an issue, record the SEDS reference number in the attribute seds_ref.

Record any changes to the EXPRESS in:

dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp
dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp

OTHER issues

Open issue Issue: RBN-1 by Rob Bodington (06-06-19) minor_technical issue
SEDS: SEDS-1200-STEP-TS-1293
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign reference data to Representation_relationship to define the type of the relationship. Hence the classification_item select should be extended with Representation_relationship. Raise a SEDS against "ISO/TS 10303-1293:2005: AP239 part definition information"
Comment: (Rob Bodington 06-06-19)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.xml
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-02-01)
SEDS submitted: seds-10303-1293a.txt
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-02-01)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/arm_lf_p28xsd.xsd

Open issue Issue: RBN-2 by Rob Bodington (06-06-19) minor_technical issue
SEDS: SEDS-1199-STEP-TS-1289
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a date to an Approving_person_organization. Hence the date_or_date_time_item select should be extended with Approving_person_organization. Raise a SEDS against ISO/TS 10303-1289:2004: AP239 management resource information
Comment: (Rob Bodington 06-06-19)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.xml
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-02-01)
Submitted SEDS: seds-10303-1289b.txt
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-02-01)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/arm_lf_p28xsd.xsd

Open issue Issue: RBN-3 by Rob Bodington (06-06-23) minor_technical issue
SEDS: SEDS-1198-STEP-TS-1289
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a dated effectivity to classification_assignment. Hence effectivity_item should be extended with classification_assignment Raise a SEDS against ISO/TS 10303-1289:2004: AP239 management resource information
Comment: (Rob Bodington 06-06-23)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.xml
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-02-01)
SEDS submitted: seds-10303-1289a.txt
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-02-01)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/arm_lf_p28xsd.xsd

Open issue Issue: RBN-4 by Rob Bodington (07-01-31) minor_technical issue
SEDS: 1135
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

The use of message always requires the use of the escape mechanism to reference items, whereas, in some cases an AP may wish to restrict the usage to particular entities. Suggest: The entity Content_item should be subtyped (oneof) to Content_item_selected and Content_item_reference Content_item would become an abstract type, and the current attributes migrated to Content_item_reference Content_item_selected would have a single attribute pointing to an extensible select Additional Notes: An AP could chose to define the set of things a message is restricted to by a rule allowing only the Content_item_select subtype and extending the associated select.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-02-01)
added TYPE message_content_item and ENTITY Content_item_selected Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/arm_lf_p28xsd.xsd

Open issue Issue: RBN-5 by Rob Bodington (07-02-01) minor_technical issue
SEDS: SEDS-1256-STEP-TS-1293
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a description to a Justification. Right now within AP239 this requires the ability to assign a document. The use of document (as described in the template assigning_descriptor) is a temporary solution until the module description_assignment is added to AP239. Add Justification to documented_element_select
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-02-01)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/arm_lf_p28xsd.xsd
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-10-01)
SEDS submitted: SEDS-1256-STEP-TS-1293.txt

Open issue Issue: RBN-6 by Rob Bodington (07-02-01) minor_technical issue
SEDS: SEDS-1257-STEP-TS-1293
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a justification to a Property_value_representation. this will enable the reason that a property value has changed to be recorded. For example, the property recording the flying hours of an aircraft will be increased as the result of an activity (flying) performed by the aircraft. Add Property_value_representation to the select justification_item
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-02-01)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/arm_lf_p28xsd.xsd
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-10-01)
SEDS submitted: SEDS-1257-STEP-TS-1293.txt

Open issue Issue: RBN-7 by Rob Bodington (07-03-14) minor_technical issue
SEDS: 1134
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

The use of observation always requires the use of the escape mechanism to reference items, whereas, in some cases an AP may wish to restrict the usage to particular entities. Suggest: The entity Observation_item should be subtyped (oneof) to Observation_item_selected Observation_item_selected would have a single attribute pointing to an extensible select. TYPE observation_content_item = SELECT (Product, Product_version, Activity, State); END_TYPE; ENTITY Observation_item_selected SUBTYPE OF (Observation_item); contents: observation_content_item; END_ENTITY; Additional Notes: An AP could chose to define the set of things an observation is restricted to by a rule allowing only the Content_item_select subtype and extending the associated select.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-03-15)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/arm_lf_p28xsd.xsd
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-10-01)
SEDS submitted: SEDS-1255-STEP-TS-1258.txt

Open issue Issue: RBN-8 by Rob Bodington (07-03-20) minor_technical issue
SEDS: SEDS-1258-STEP-TS-1307
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a work request to a State, in order to represent the fact that a given state should be addressed by a work request. E.g. A request to address a fault state. Extend the select affected_item_select with State and State_definition
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-03-20)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/arm_lf_p28xsd.xsd
Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-10-01)
SEDS submitted: SEDS-1258-STEP-TS-1307.txt

Open issue Issue: GYL-1 by Leif Gyllstrom (07-05-02) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a document (description) to Condition_assignment as well as to Condition_parameter. E.g. descriptions. Extend the select documented_element_select with Condition_assignment and Condition_parameter.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-18)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-2 by Leif Gyllstrom (07-05-02) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a Justification to: Condition_assignment and Applied_state_definition_assignment E.g. descriptions. Extend the select justification_item with Condition_assignment and Applied_state_definition_assignment
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-18)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-3 by Leif Gyllstrom (07-08-23) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a Document to Class. Extend the documented_element_select for Document_assignment.is_assigned_to with Class.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-18)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-4 by Leif Gyllstrom (07-08-23) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Identification_assignment to Class. Extend the identification_item for Identification_assignment.items with Class.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-19)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-5 by Leif Gyllstrom (07-08-23) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Effectivity_assignment to Independent_property_representation. Extend the effectivity_item for Effectivity_assignment.items with Independent_property_representation.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-19)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-6 by Leif Gyllstrom (07-08-23) major_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

Enhance the Required_resource_by_specification" according to the figure below.

Figure 1 —  Suggested ARM extensions

Figure 1 —  Suggested ARM extensions

Open issue Issue: GYL-7 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-01-28) major_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an In_zone to Activity_method and Applied_activity_method_assignment. Extend the in_zone_item for In-zone.located_item with Activity_method and Applied_activity_method_assignment.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-19)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-8 by Leif Gyllstrom (07-08-23) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a Document to Document_assignment. Extend the documented_element_select for Document_assignment.is_assigned_to with Document_assignment.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-19)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-9 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Effectivity to Activity_property_representation. Extend effectivity_item for Effectivity.items with Activity_property_representation.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-28)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-10 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Effectivity to Condition_assignment. Extend effectivity_item for Effectivity.items with Condition_assignment.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-28)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-12 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Effectivity to Resource_property_representation. Extend effectivity_item for Effectivity.items with Resource_property_representation.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-28)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-13 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Effectivity to View_definition_usage. Extend effectivity_item for Effectivity.items with View_definition_usage.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-28)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-14 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Condition_parameter to Product_configuration. Extend condition_parameter_item for Condition_parameter.parameter with Product_configuration.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-28)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-15 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Condition_parameter to Organization. Extend condition_parameter_item for Condition_parameter.parameter with Organization.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 08-02-28)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: MWD-1 by Mike Ward (2008-01-09) minor_technical issue
SEDS: SEDS-1272-STEP-TS-1293
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a Applied_state_assignment to an Approval, in order to represent the state (or status) on an Approval in a way that is consistent with other state assignments in AP239. Extend the state_of_item SELECT with Approval
Comment: (Mike Ward 2008-01-09)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/arm_lf_p28xsd.xsd
Comment: (Mike Ward 2008-01-091)
SEDS submitted: SEDS-1272-STEP-TS-1293" Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.xml

Open issue Issue: GYL-16 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-03-09) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a Condition to an Effectivity. Extend condition_item for Condition_assignment.item with Effectivity.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 08-03-10)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xsd dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-17 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Condition_parameter to Organization_type. Extend condition_parameter_item for Condition_parameter.parameter with Organization_type.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 11-03-10)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xsd dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-18 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign a Condition to Activity_method and its subtypes. Extend condition_item for Condition_assignment.item with Activity_method.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 11-03-10)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xsd dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-19 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Condition_parameter to Independent_property. Extend condition_parameter_item for Condition_parameter.parameter with Independent_property.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 11-03-10)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xsd dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

Open issue Issue: GYL-20 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

It should be possible to assign an Condition_parameter to Work_request. Extend condition_parameter_item for Condition_parameter.parameter with Work_request.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 11-03-10)
Updated: dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.exp dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xml dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_lf.xsd dexlib/data/schemas/ap239_arm_sf.exp

OTHER issues

Closed issue Issue: GYL-11 by Leif Gyllstrom (08-02-25) minor_technical issue
SEDS: NOT YET RAISED
Resolution: Reject. Status: closed

It should be possible to assign an Effectivity to Classification_assignment. Extend effectivity_item for Effectivity.items with Classification_assignment.
Comment: (Johan Nielsen 2008-02-28)
Classification_assingment is already part of effectivity_item, see RBN-3/SEDS-1198-STEP-TS-1289.