http://docs.oasis-open.org/ws-dd/issues/
WS-DD TC Issues List
Date: 2009/03/16
Revision: 022
spec
schema
soap
wsdl
policy
rddl
all
Review
Active
Deferred
Dropped
Pending
Done
Resolved
Closed
DPWS - Clarify R4032 and R0436 w.r.t. other multicast bindings
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Define matching for empty Action filter
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Fault Action should use lowercase 'f'
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Faulting to non-anonymous endpoints
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - SOAP Binding should apply to clients
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
SOAP-over-UDP - WSDL binding for SOAP-over-UDP
See email.
soap-over-udp
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This was deferred (to a future revision of the specification) during
December 23, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Old version of WS-Addressing
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
November 18, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - XAddrs not controlled by MetadataVersion
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This was dropped during
December 02, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarify matching rule rfc2396
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 11, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarify handling of multihomed devices
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This was deferred (to a future revision of the specification) during
December 23, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Terminology
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 11, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Add size constraint to SOAP-over-UDP messages
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 11, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Restrict encoding of SOAP messages to UTF-8
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Locating the services by Binding
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
This issue was dropped during
November 11, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Obsolete requirement R0007
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 11, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Edit R0042
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Support relative URLs for hosted services
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This issue was deferred for later consideration during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Move Application Sequencing from Appendix to main specification
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Combine security section under a single top level heading
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - XSD and WSDL files as separate resources
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clearly define Discovery Proxy in the specification
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
Closed with no action during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Request-Response MEP for communicating with proxy
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
See changes in document.
The proposal 2 was approved during the
October 21, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarify use of AppSequence and related fields
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
Suggested text:
Identifies a sequence of related messages within the context of an instance identifier. If omitted, implied value is
the null sequence. MUST be unique within ./@InstanceId. MUST be compared per RFC 3986 Section 6.2.1 Simple String
Comparison [RFC 3986]. The ordering of messages with different value of SequenceId but the same value of InstanceId
within the Application Sequencing Header block is undefined.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - R1013 and R1015 should clarify directed discovery
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Add a description language for relating device types and service types
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This was deferred (to next version) during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - WS-Eventing does not work when subscriber in not addressable
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
It is better to address this in the WS-Eventing specification (defined by the W3C WS-ResourceAccess WG).
TC agreed to defer this issue for later consideration during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarification on accepting unicast Probe
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 27, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Review constants
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution is already part of Committee Draft 1. Close this issue. This was approved during
December 02, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Clarify use of WS-Policy for devices
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Restrict WSDL to be provided as references (not inline)
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
Closed (issue i085 address this) during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
i085
DPWS - Bring BP 2.0 in scope (for WSDL)
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
Deferred for later processing. This was agreed to during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Clarify behavior when a device contains secure and insecure services at the same time
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarify use of AppSequence and related fields
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
Dropped since it is a duplicate of issue i023. The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
i023
WS-Discovery - Discovery proxy and multicast suppression requirement
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
See changes in document.
The proposal 2 was approved during the
October 21, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Define protocol assignment/binding for managed mode
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
See changes in document.
The proposal 2 was approved during the
October 21, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Discovery messages and managed mode
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
See changes in document.
The proposal 2 was approved during the
October 21, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Additional information in Host element
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This was dropped (due to issue i038 resolution) during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
i038
DPWS - Endpoint reference for Host
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 23, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Recursive hosting
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 23, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - PresentationURL in ThisDevice instead of ThisModel metadata
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
Proposed Text:
"dpws:ThisModel/ dpws resentationUrl
URL to a presentation resource for this DEVICE. It MAY be relative to a base URL and MUST have fewer than
MAX_URI_SIZE octets. If PresentationUrl is specified, the DEVICE MAY provide the resource in multiple formats,
but MUST at least provide an HTML page. CLIENTs and DEVICEs MAY use HTTP content negotiation [HTTP/1.1] to
determine the format and content of the presentation resource."
Proposed addition:
"DEVICEs that use a relative URL MAY use HTTP Redirection 3xx codes [HTTP/1.1] to direct CLIENTs to a dedicated
web server running on another port."
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 23, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Require the use of replyTo in Request/Reply exchanges
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This was dropped during
December 02, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Allow use of replyTo with non-anonymous addresses
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This issue was dropped (as a result of resolution of issue i083) during
November 18, 2008 TC meeting.
i083
DPWS - Remove justification on the use of new Types
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 30, 2008 TC call.
DPWS - Use standard Request/Reply MEP in directed probe
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
Dropped as a duplicate during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - EndpointReference sub-element
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Make assumption in R2043 explicit
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 23, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Replace reference to RFC 2396 with RFC 3986
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Probe requirement in ResolveMatch section
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Forced managed mode transition for the client
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
See changes in document.
The proposal 2 was approved during the
October 21, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - The UUIDs URIs do not use UUID URN Namespace defined by RFC 4122
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Generalize security restrictions in DPWS and integrate different sources available today
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 27, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Issue of event filtering
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Shin Ohtake
Shin Ohtake
See email.
Closed (no specification changes) with an action (for white paper team to incorporate developer guidance
and chairs to respond to issue originator) during
January 20, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Announcement messages in case of managed mode
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This issue was deferred for later consideration during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Remove support for SOAP 1.1
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Update to latest version of WS-Addressing and impact on ServiceID
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Reduce amount of notifications by requiring XPATH support for filtering
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
Closed (no specification changes) with an action (for white paper team to incorporate developer guidance
and chairs to respond to issue originator) during
January 20, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Clearly define how HOSTED SERVICES types are exposed by the device in the discovery messages
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
Dropped as a duplicate of i025. This was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
i025
WS-Discovery - Remove transport specification retransmission notes in ProbeMatch and ResolveMatch sections
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Follow WSDL naming conventions in naming messages and part names
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - RelationshipType attribute is not required
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
Dropped since it is a duplicate of issue i066. This was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
i066
DPWS/WS-Discovery - Assign an OASIS namespace for the specifications
See email.
dpws
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Description of Scopes element for Probe does not mention that whitespace is not allowed
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarify matching behavior for empty d:Types, d:Scopes element
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarify matching algorithm for @MatchBy, @Scheme and @SequenceId
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Terminologies should not make normative text like statements
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - RelationshipType attribute is not required
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Define KeyID content in the d:Sig
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
September 16-18, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Use xml:id instead of d:Id
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
This issue was dropped during
October 14, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Preventing replay attack using [message id] property is impractical
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was accepted during
January 06, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Content negotiation for PresentationUrl
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Gottfried Zimmermann
Gottfried Zimmermann
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Upgrade version of WS-Policy
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Text edit: Missing space
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
October 14, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - definition for "stable" ID
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 25, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Purpose behind dup requirements?
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
Editors to put the new statement after R0036.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 18, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Define Target Service
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
October 14, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Clarify placement of dpws policy assertion
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
This issue was dropped during
October 14, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Duplicate requirements around Push mode
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
October 14, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Transport addresses referred to as EPR
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
Addressed in the document - see email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 18, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Too many normative statements in Section 2 Terminology and Notations
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Secure all WSA related headers
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 11, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Use "urn:uuid" scheme for UUID scope matching rule
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 25, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Reconsider transition to managed mode
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
This was closed during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting
with the understanding that this would be addressed in the white paper (by adding guidance material).
DPWS - Scope of wsa:ReplyTo
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 18, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Service Subscribe Fault Clarification
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 25, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Possible confusion around use of MEX
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
Editors to modify proposal 1 to clarify the MEX getMetadata is to be used for hosted services and WS-Transfer Get
is to be used for DEVICE metadata.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Example Hello sent in managed mode does not define "i"
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 02, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Incorrect reference to RFC 5280
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Using whitespaces in the expanded signature can result in different digest values
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Namespace of a Type can be altered in a secure discovery message
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Compact Signature outline does not include the datatype for Refs attribute
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
Minor amendment to proposal: Change IDEREFS to IDREFS.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 02, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Minor Editorial issues in Section 8.2
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 02, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - RFC Format Change for R3019
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 02, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Clarify R3008 vs R3012
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Clarification on time-type for Subscription Duration
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
Add text: "Event Sources are required to have an internal clock, but there is no requirement that the clock be
synchronized with clients or other HOSTED SERVICEs. Event Sources are only required to support Expirations
expressed in duration, but they should attempt to match the type of the Subscription Expiration when possible.
If the value or type of the Expiration is unacceptable, the Event Source may select an appropriate Expiration
and return it in the Subscribe Response or Renew Response.". Remove R3005 and R3006.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Clarification on Fault Handling of Subscription ExpirationType
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Scott de Deugd
Scott de Deugd
See email.
Closed with no action (due to i094 resolution) during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
i094
WS-Discovery - Clarify meaning of "device leaving the network"
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
Suggested text for Bye:
A Target Service SHOULD send a Bye message when it is preparing to leave a network, such as when it will no longer
be accessible through one or more of its advertised transport addresses, in a controlled shutdown, or when an
address change is being initiated by the service.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarify meaning of "device joining the network"
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
Suggested text for Hello:
A Target Service MUST send a Hello message when it joins a network, including when it becomes available though
one or more additional transport addresses. This may be detected through low-level mechanisms, such as wireless
beacons, or through a change in IP connectivity on one or more of its network interfaces.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS/WS-Discovery - Assign an OASIS namespace for Committee Draft 2
See email.
dpws
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - typo in URI
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - typo in introduction
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - typo in section 2.1
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - typo in section 3.1
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - typos in section 3.2
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
Discovery - clarify case where a TS doesn't specify a Type
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - editorial changes in section 3.3
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - redundant mentions of "one way"
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - typos in section 3.1 (with DP)
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - clarify "stable identifier"
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 23, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Update references
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS - Support for TLS_RSA_WITH_RC4_128_SHA
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dave Whitehead
Dave Whitehead
See email.
The TC decided not to make this change as proposed. But the TC agreed to make a stronger recommendation
about the current use of TLS 1.1 - the editors are on point to make this change. This changed was agreed to during
January 06, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Reference to TLS specification
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dave Whitehead
Dave Whitehead
See email.
Use of TLS 1.2 is not widely prevalent - browsers do not support this yet fully. This issue was dropped during
January 06, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Remove reference to WS-Security
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 27, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Clean up Network Model section
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 27, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Remove Security Association section
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 27, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Fix R4070 to use xAddrs
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 27, 2009 TC meeting.
SOAP-over-UDP - Update references and related changes
See email.
soap-over-udp
spec
design
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 16, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Merge R019 and R2020
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 16, 2008 TC meeting
with the editorial action to replace "implied" to "clarifies" in the proposed resolution.
WS-Discovery - Add missing text for adding Algorithmsuite attribute in the expanded signature elements (editorial)
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 16, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarify that the DigestValue element inside the Reference element should be populated with the computed digest value (editorial)
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 16, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - References update
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
See email.
Proposal 1 and 2 were approved during
December 16, 2008 TC meeting
with the understanding that references to WS-Trust and WS-SecureConversation will be updated to OASIS Standard
version (v1.4) of those specification in February 09 (when they are expected to be available).
DPWS - Consistency problem with the metadata version in WS-discovery and the metadata of devices
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
This was dropped (as duplicate of i133) during
December 16, 2008 TC meeting.
i133
WS-Discovery - MessageNumber rollover
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 16, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Remove special "ad-hoc" scope
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was accepted during
January 06, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - xAddrs in ResolveMatches issue
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Finding services require a double round trip
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
See email. Editors to update the
definition of Resolve Match accordingly.
Proposal 2 was approved during
December 23, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - KeyId complexity in compact signatures
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Change schema for Relationship metadata element
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Remove reference to discovery in hosted services type description
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 16, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Update WS-Transfer, MEX, WS-Eventing references to W3C Recommendation version (when available)
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
The was deferred (for future processing in a later revision) during
December 16, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS - Fault handling clarification needed
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Travis M Grigsby
Travis M Grigsby
See email.
Modifications to original proposal (proposal 1): Change requirement R3020 from MUST to SHOULD; also remove explanatory text.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Problem with SOAP address of services on a device
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Elmar Zeeb
Elmar Zeeb
See email.
Closed (no specification changes) with an action (for white paper team to incorporate developer guidance) during
January 20, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - How to define base url for presentation url in metadata
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Elmar Zeeb
Elmar Zeeb
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was accepted during
January 06, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - metadataversion in metadata
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Ingo Lueck
Ingo Lueck
See email.
This was dropped during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - No reliable way to retrieve discovery metadata of devices
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Elmar Zeeb
Elmar Zeeb
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was accepted during
January 06, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - No reliable way to retrieve port types of services
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Elmar Zeeb
Elmar Zeeb
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
SOAP-over-UDP - UNICAST_UDP_REPEAT and MULTICAST_UDP_REPEAT constant values
See email.
soap-over-udp
spec
design
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Discovery/Service types WSDL attribute
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email. Editors to write up the
specific text of the resolution.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Create security model introduction
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 27, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Remove security negotiation
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 27, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Clean up HTTP authentication
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
See email.
Proposal 2 was approved during
January 27, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - fix wrong references in Section 6.3 (editorial)
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
January 06, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Remove wildcard from the normativeoutline descriptions (editorial)
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
January 06, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Change *_UDP_REPEAT constants in DPWS to 1
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Editorial: replace the >= 1 symbol with the text
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Editorial: clarify that the security header should not be signed
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
January 13, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Conformance must require implementing atleast one of the prescribed roles
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
January 20, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Clarification on accepting unicast Probe
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Alain Regnier
Alain Regnier
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
February 17, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Editorial - Reorganize Section 7
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
February 25, 2009 TC F2F meeting.
WS-Discovery - Update WS-SecureConversation and WS-Trust references to latest version
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
February 10, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Add pointer and binding to schema file
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
February 10, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Editorial - Reformat terminology and references so they matches other WS-DD specs
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
February 10, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Editorial - Move example in Section 1 after the terminology section
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
editorial
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
February 10, 2009 TC meeting.
SOAP-over-UDP - Editorial - Citations are not well-formed
See email.
soap-over-udp
spec
editorial
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
February 10, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Editorial - Rectify change collision on R0031
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Dan Driscoll
Dan Driscoll
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
February 17, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - Update XML Schema references to Second Edition
See email.
dpws
spec
editorial
Ram Jeyaraman
Ram Jeyaraman
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
February 17, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery interop scenarios - Allow additionaltypes to be sent in WS-Discovery messages used in WS-Discovery interop scenarios
See email.
ws-discovery-interop-scenarios
spec
design
Antoine Mensch
Antoine Mensch
See email.
Editors to change scenario descriptions to allow for additional scopes and types.
Proposal 2 was approved during
November 25, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery interop scenarios - wrong schema for CalculatorService WSDL
See email.
ws-discovery-interop-scenarios
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
November 25, 2008 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery interop scenarios - Clarification to Scenario 4.2.1
See email.
ws-discovery-interop-scenarios
spec
design
Vipul Modi
Vipul Modi
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 02, 2008 TC meeting.
DPWS interop scenarios - Wrong URI for action filter
See email.
dpws-interop-scenarios
spec
design
Elmar Zeeb
Elmar Zeeb
See email.
The proposed resolution was approved during
December 10-11, 2008 F2F meeting.
DPWS/WS-Discovery/SOAP-over-UDP - Use of DOCX format for editable source
See email.
dpws
ws-discovery
soap-over-udp
spec
editorial
Stephen Green
Stephen Green
This issue was dropped (see reason) during
February 10, 2009 TC meeting.
DPWS - SOAP 1.2 HTTP transport binding URI conflict
See email.
dpws
spec
design
Stephan Poehlsen
Stephan Poehlsen
This was dropped (see reason) during
February 17, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Use of IPv6 link-local and routable IPaddresses
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Stephan Poehlsen
Stephan Poehlsen
This was deferred (see reason) for future consideration for white paper or guidance material during
February 17, 2009 TC meeting.
WS-Discovery - Clarification on Hello message
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Jay A. Treptow
Jay A. Treptow
This was dropped during
March 10, 2009 TC meeting.
Since the suggested use case is already enabled by the specification, the TC decided that there is no need to clarify this.
WS-Discovery - SignedInfo element is not in XML-C14N canonical form
See email.
ws-discovery
spec
design
Jay A. Treptow
Jay A. Treptow
SOAP-over-UDP - Comment on WSDL binding
See email.
soap-over-udp
spec
design
Sylvain Marié
Sylvain Marié